I haven't used the other all weather liners before but these seem to be pretty descent quality for the price. It seems durable and will do the job of keeping the carpet from wear and tear. when I installed it, it didn't seem like it was going to fit but after being in the warm car and settling, it looks pretty good. not "perfect" but it works.
I have always been a weather tech guy when it comes to all season mats but I saw these on sale and figured I'd give them a try. After receiving these mats, I couldn't be more pleased with the quality, performance, and fit. Also the rear mat was available in a one piece covering the middle as well. Weather tech only offered a two piece rear mat for my make and model. Look great and would highly recommend