Reviewed by IRIS M (MIAMI, FL) — Thursday at 8:13 PM

Unfortunately we bought the bag to travel from Miami to Orlando driving speed limit on the Turnpike of 70 miles per hr and around 1 hr and a half from Orlando we heard in the roof like a tapping zone. When we stopped to check what was going on the bag had ripped on one side and it was totally opened. We where able to make it to Orlando like this but at a slower speed to avoid anymore breakage. The bag is a good idea if only the workmanship of it is extremely strong and approved for wind.

Reviewed by Janet M (BROOMFIELD, CO) Reviewed for a 2012 Honda Pilot — Mar 30, 2013 9:08 AM

I got the rooftop carrier for a family road trip. Once installed we were able to fit all of our luggage so the kids had more room in the car. We left during a blizzard so the bag was subject to ice, wind, and snow for 300 miles of our trip. When we got to our final destination the bag was in tact and the luggage was dry. The bag worked as advertised, the one draw back would be that the bulky shape of the bag may have caused some wind resistence.

Reviewed by Mark R M (Oceanside, NY) Reviewed for a 2004 Lincoln Navigator — Jan 27, 2013 3:02 PM

I think I received a defective cargo bag. The bag openned on one seam and the zipper broke near the beginning.

Reviewed by Jamie H (Montgomery, AL) Reviewed for a 2011 Ford Expedition — Dec 27, 2012 10:20 AM

Bought this cargo bag for a trip to Disneyworld. Used it one time on the way home and it ripped apart letting in water and our luggage was soaked and ruined.

Reviewed by Carol N (ENNIS, TX) Reviewed for a 2012 Hyundai Santa Fe — Nov 27, 2012 11:00 AM

When we received the cargo bag, I was a little worried about how small it looked. No worries! It held all of our luggage for our ski trip! We had plenty of room inside the car for our children! Great product!

Reviewed by PATRICIA H (louisville, KY) Reviewed for a 2009 Kia Sportage — Sep 21, 2012 9:54 PM

it was great. went on a all women vacation and we were able to handle it ourselves and it didn't budge.

Reviewed by Theresa J (PONTE VEDRA, FL) Reviewed for a 2012 Chevy Equinox — Sep 16, 2012 1:49 PM

I have tried other roof top carriers and the Heininger SofTop Roof Top Cargo Bag out performs others that I have tried. I am impressed with the Appearance, Ease of installation, PRICE and Quality if the Heininger SofTop Roof Top Cargo Bag.

Reviewed by Danilo II G (Los Angeles, CA) Reviewed for a 2008 Toyota RAV4 — Sep 15, 2012 10:41 PM

Very pleased with my recent purchase. I rated all 4 because of their quality , appearance, value of $. Although i have not installed it yet but i can tell that its a piece of cake to install approximately 10minutes. My only concerns is the length of the belt which i believe will an annoying sound once you drove, however you need to secure properly. This is a good product for the quality value and i highly recommend for those who would like this product.

Reviewed by Sharilyn M (SEDRO WOOLLEY, WA) Reviewed for a 2000 Honda CR-V — Sep 06, 2012 8:26 PM

It's huge, 13 cubic ft. Works great! And talk about prompt! we got it the next day!

Reviewed by Mark M (OWEGO, NY) Reviewed for a 2000 Jeep Cherokee — Sep 06, 2012 11:17 AM

I bought this rooftop cargo bag at the last minute before leaving for a week long camping trip. It worked great and was much cheaper than the hard shell rooftop case that I was considering. I believe that it actually has more storage capacity than most of the hard shell cases. It was raining when we left, yet everything remained dry. Very good value.